Skip to main content

Free guides to the law for parish, town and community councils

Guides for: Wales

We remember this choice with one cookie on this device, and use it for nothing else. Forget my choice

Can a councillor who has already said what they think about a matter still speak and vote on it?

England and Wales. Last checked against the source on .

In short

Yes: having said what they think does not, on its own, stop a councillor speaking and voting. Section 25 of the Localism Act 2011 does not say so in so many words, but it follows from what it does say. If a council decision is later questioned for bias or predetermination, a councillor is not to be treated as having had, or seemed to have had, a closed mind just because of anything they said or did earlier that showed what view they took, or would or might take, on something relevant to it. But:

  • Whether they really had, or seemed to have, a closed mind when the decision was made can still matter to whether the decision is valid, and other evidence can be used to show it.
  • In England, a councillor who knows they have a disclosable pecuniary interest in the matter, one of the kinds of financial interest the law lists, must not take part in the discussion or vote on it at a meeting, unless the council has given them a dispensation. Doing so without a reasonable excuse is a criminal offence. The council's own code of conduct may ask for more, on interests or on how councillors reach decisions.
  • In Wales, a councillor with a prejudicial interest in the matter must leave the room when the meeting comes to it, and must not otherwise try to influence the decision, unless the standards committee of their county or county borough council has given them a dispensation. Where the public may speak on it, the councillor may do the same first, and may also send the meeting their views in writing, following any procedure the council has set.
  • In Wales, the code of conduct also says that a councillor who takes part in a meeting or reaches a decision must do so on the merits of the case and in the public interest, having regard to any relevant advice from the council's officers.

Applies to: Every councillor of a parish or town council in England, or of a community or town council in Wales, whether they were elected or not, for example co-opted. It also covers anyone who is not a councillor but has a vote on one of the council's committees or sub-committees, or represents it with a vote on a joint committee or joint sub-committee. It does not cover the clerk or any other officer. Section 25 does not list a parish meeting in a parish that has no council.

What the law says

This is dealt with in section 25 of the Localism Act 2011, which applies in England and in Wales. It names parish councils and community councils among the councils it covers, together with district, county, county borough and London borough councils and some other authorities. So a councillor who also sits on one of those councils is covered there too.

It comes into play when two things are true:

  • there is a question about whether a decision of the council is valid, because someone alleges bias or predetermination, or for any other reason; and
  • it matters to that question whether a councillor taking the decision had, or seemed to have, a closed mind to any extent when it was made.

In that case, the councillor is not to be treated as having had, or seemed to have had, a closed mind just because:

  • they had earlier done anything that showed, directly or indirectly, what view they took, or would or might take, on a matter; and
  • that matter was relevant to the decision.

The section gives no examples, but it speaks of "anything" that showed the councillor's view. So it would take in, for example, something said at a public meeting, written in an election leaflet, said to the press or posted online, or a vote at an earlier meeting. Nor does it limit how long before the decision the thing was done, so it would take in what someone did before they became a councillor.

The section covers decisions made in carrying out the council's functions, whether by the full council, a committee or a sub-committee.

What the law does not do

  • It does not say a closed mind can never be shown. It stops what a councillor said or did earlier counting, on its own, as proof that they had, or seemed to have, a closed mind. This section does not say so in so many words, but it follows from the words "just because": other evidence of how the councillor approached the decision can still be weighed.
  • It does not create the rule against bias and predetermination. That rule comes from the courts. This page does not set out what the courts have decided.
  • It deals with whether a decision is valid. It does not mention the code of conduct, so it does not say whether an earlier statement of view could count in a complaint that a councillor broke the code.

Interests are a separate question

Having said what they think is one thing. Having an interest in the matter is another, and section 25 does nothing to lift the rules on interests.

Owing council tax may also affect a councillor's vote on the budget and the precept: see Can a councillor who owes council tax vote on the budget or the precept?

In Wales: the code of conduct

Every community council's code of conduct must include the rules of the model code of conduct for Wales, which are all compulsory. One of them says that a councillor must, "when participating in meetings or reaching decisions regarding the business of your authority, do so on the basis of the merits of the circumstances involved and in the public interest having regard to any relevant advice provided by your authority's officers".

The model code says it should be read with the principles of conduct set for councillors in Wales. The principle on objectivity says that councillors must make decisions on merit. They must have regard to officers' professional advice and may properly take account of other people's views, their political group's included, but "it is their responsibility to decide what view to take and, if appropriate, how to vote on any issue."

Section 25 deals with whether a decision is valid, and does not mention the code. Complaints that a councillor broke the code are dealt with separately: see Who deals with a complaint that a community councillor in Wales has broken the code of conduct?

In England: the council's own code of conduct

A parish council in England must adopt a code of conduct. It may adopt the code of its principal authority: the district council where there is one, the London borough council in a London borough, and otherwise the county council. Viewed as a whole, the code must be consistent with seven principles, one of which is objectivity. Read the council's code to see whether it says anything more about how councillors reach decisions.

A failure to follow the code does not, by itself, make a decision invalid. The law says that "a decision is not invalidated just because something that occurred in the process of making the decision involved a failure to comply with the code". Complaints that a councillor broke the code are dealt with separately: see Who deals with a complaint that a parish councillor in England has broken the code of conduct?

Example

A councillor wrote in their election leaflet that they would support a new play area. Later the council decides to build one, and the councillor speaks and votes for it. Assume they have no interest in the matter of the kinds described above. If someone challenges the decision, the leaflet is not, on its own, to be taken as showing that the councillor had, or seemed to have, a closed mind.

What this page does not cover

Sources

All read as revised.

  • Localism Act 2011: section 25 (prior indications of view), section 239 (extent) and section 240 (subsection (1), section 25's coming into force); for England, section 27 (the duty to have a code), section 28 (subsections (1) to (4), the principles, what a code may contain, and decisions not invalidated), section 29 (subsection (9), the principal authority), section 30 (subsection (3), what a disclosable pecuniary interest is), section 31 (subsections (1) and (4), taking part with a disclosable pecuniary interest), section 33 (dispensations) and section 34 (subsection (1), the offence)
  • Local Government Act 1972: section 245 (subsection (6), a town council in England) and section 245B (a town council in Wales)
  • Local Government Act 2000: section 49 (principles for Wales), section 50 (the model code) and section 51 (the council's code must include its compulsory rules)
  • The Local Authorities (Model Code of Conduct) (Wales) Order 2008: article 3 (the rules are compulsory), and the model code in its Schedule, paragraphs 1 (meanings, and the standards committee for a community council), 2 (when the code applies, and the principles), 8 (deciding on the merits), 12 (what a prejudicial interest is) and 14 (leaving the room with a prejudicial interest)
  • The Conduct of Members (Principles) (Wales) Order 2001: article 2 (meanings), article 3 and the Schedule, paragraph 6 (objectivity in decision-making)

The official website shows section 25 as up to date to 15 November 2026, and the other provisions of the three Acts as up to date to between 14 and 17 November 2026. For each of the three Acts, the changes it lists as not yet applied are to other provisions, such as section 158 of the Localism Act 2011, which this page does not rely on. It lists none for the provisions of the 2008 and 2001 orders that were read.

Last checked against the source on 17 November 2026.