In short
Some of these faults are covered by the law and some are not. A council's decisions are not made invalid just because a seat was empty, or because something was wrong with a councillor's election or qualifications. A council meeting is not made invalid just because a councillor was not served with their summons. These rules do not say whether a decision stands if it was taken without a quorum, at a meeting whose public notice was not given or one held online in England, or with a councillor taking part who was barred by a disclosable pecuniary interest in England or a prejudicial interest in Wales. That would be for a court.
- A disqualified councillor: if a person elected as a councillor was disqualified, what they did as a councillor still counts as if they had been qualified. They can still be taken to court for acting while disqualified.
- A co-opted councillor, or someone who had already stopped being a councillor: these rules do not clearly say how far they reach them.
- The summons rule speaks only of a summons that was not served, not of one that was late or did not set out the business, or of any other notice of the meeting.
- Minutes signed in the way the law sets are treated as showing that the meeting was properly called and held, and the councillors present properly qualified, until the opposite is proved.
- In England, a decision is not invalid just because a councillor broke the council's code of conduct while it was being made.
Applies to: Every parish and town council in England and every community and town council in Wales. The rules on empty seats, faults in a member's election or qualifications, and signed minutes also apply to the council's committees and sub-committees.
An empty seat, or a fault in a councillor's election or qualifications
The rule, the same in both countries, is that a council's proceedings "shall not be invalidated by any vacancy among their number or by any defect in the election or qualifications of any member thereof". So a decision is not invalid just because seats were empty when it was taken, or because it later turns out that something was wrong with how a councillor was elected or with their qualifications. The same rule applies to the council's committees and sub-committees, including a joint committee with other councils.
A council meeting still needs its quorum. To be safe it is worked out counting every seat, empty or not, apart from one rare case described under the quorum below. If so many seats are empty that the council cannot reach a quorum, see What happens if not enough people stand for election to a parish or community council? Who is qualified is on Who is qualified to be a parish or community councillor?
A councillor who was disqualified or not qualified
A second rule, also the same in both countries, covers what the councillor does. If a person elected as a councillor was disqualified, or did not have the qualifications, what they did as a councillor, such as voting, is "as valid and effectual as if he had been qualified".
That rule protects what was done, not the person. A local government elector for the area (a person registered to vote in local elections there), and only an elector, can take someone to court for acting, or claiming to be entitled to act, as a councillor while disqualified. A case about acting must be started within six months of the act. The court can make the person pay for each time they acted, and the High Court can also declare the seat vacant and order them to stop. What disqualifies someone is on What disqualifies someone from being a parish councillor in England? and What disqualifies someone from being a community councillor in Wales?
Someone who had already lost their seat. A councillor can stop being one without being disqualified, for example by not making the declaration of acceptance of office in time, by resigning, or by not attending meetings. For the court cases above, such a person counts as disqualified for acting. But the two rules that protect decisions do not say whether they reach someone who had already stopped being a councillor before the meeting. See When does a new councillor have to sign the declaration of acceptance of office? and What happens if a councillor misses meetings for six months?
A councillor who was co-opted
A co-opted councillor is chosen to fill an empty seat without an election, either after a seat falls vacant between elections or after an election with too few candidates.
- What the councillor does. The rule that what a disqualified councillor does is valid speaks of a person "elected" to an office. It does not mention a person who was co-opted.
- The council's proceedings. The rule on empty seats and defects speaks of "any member". A co-opted councillor fills a seat on the council, so is one of its members. The rule does not say so in so many words, but on this guide's reading its words on a defect in the "qualifications of any member" cover them. It does not say whether that covers a co-opted councillor who was disqualified, as opposed to one who lacked a qualification, or whether a fault in the co-option itself counts as a defect in their "election".
A meeting that was not properly called
The summons. Before each meeting of the council, every councillor must be sent a summons that sets out the business. In both countries, if a councillor is not served with their summons, that does not affect the validity of the meeting. The rule speaks only of a summons that was not served. It says nothing of:
- a summons that went out late, or did not set out the business;
- the notice of the meeting that must be put up in the parish or community (in Wales, also published online);
- the public notice that a separate Act, the Public Bodies (Admission to Meetings) Act 1960, requires for a meeting the public may attend.
What notice must be given is on How much notice must a parish council give of a meeting, and does it have to be online? and How must a community council in Wales give notice of a meeting?
Signed minutes. "Until the contrary is proved", a meeting of the council whose minutes were drawn up and signed in the way the law sets is treated as having been properly called and held, and all the members present as properly qualified. For a meeting of a committee or sub-committee, the committee or sub-committee is also treated as properly set up, and as having had the power to deal with what the minute records. How minutes are signed is on Do council minutes have to be signed, and can they be kept on loose leaves?
A meeting without a quorum
No business may be done at a meeting of the council unless at least one-third of the whole number of its members, and never fewer than three, are present. In one rare case, when more than a third of the members become disqualified at the same time, the third is worked out from the members still qualified, until the members in office are back up to at least two-thirds of the whole number. How to work out the quorum is on What is the quorum for a council meeting, and how are votes taken?
The quorum rule does not say what follows if business is done without a quorum, and the rule on empty seats and defects does not mention the quorum. Whether a decision taken without a quorum stands would be for a court.
If councillors leave and fewer than the quorum are left, the rule does not say in so many words whether business can go on. It says no business may be done unless the quorum is present, so the safe course is to do no further business.
A meeting held online
England. The quorum rule counts the members "present at the meeting", and a question is decided by a majority of the members "present and voting". Whether a councillor in England who joins by video counts as present is on Can a parish council in England meet online, or count a councillor who joins by video as present? If a parish council in England met online, or counted a councillor on video towards the quorum or took their vote, these rules do not say whether its decisions stand; that too would be for a court.
Wales. A community council must make and publish arrangements so that its meetings can be held with people who are not in the same place. At a meeting held that way, a person who attends by those means counts as present. See Can a community council in Wales meet remotely, and what must it publish about it?
A councillor who took part when barred by an interest
England. A councillor who knows they have a disclosable pecuniary interest in a matter at a meeting (one of the kinds of financial interest that go in the register of interests) must not take part in the discussion or vote on it, unless the council has given them a dispensation. Taking part without a reasonable excuse is a criminal offence. The sections that set this bar and the offence do not say whether a decision stands if a barred councillor took part.
A separate rule says that "a decision is not invalidated just because something that occurred in the process of making the decision involved a failure to comply with the code" of conduct. So a decision is not invalid just because a councillor broke the council's code, such as a rule in it on interests other than disclosable pecuniary interests. A council's code must also deal with pecuniary interests, so a barred councillor who takes part may break the code as well as the Act, and that rule does not say whether it then covers the breach of the Act. Whether such a decision stands would be for a court. See When does a parish councillor in England have to leave the discussion of a matter they have an interest in, and when can they be given a dispensation? and What does a parish councillor in England have to put in the register of interests?
Wales. The model code of conduct for Wales, whose rules are mandatory, requires a councillor with a prejudicial interest in business (the Welsh code's term for an interest that bars a councillor from taking part) to leave the room, unless the standards committee has given them a dispensation. There are exceptions, such as staying to speak where the public may also speak, and conditions on using a dispensation. The code's rule does not say whether a decision stands if a councillor stays and takes part; that would be for a court. An investigation by the Public Services Ombudsman for Wales into a complaint that the code was broken does not by itself affect the validity of anything the council has done. See When does a community councillor in Wales have to leave the room?
A contract made without following standing orders
A contract is not made invalid just because the council did not follow its standing orders on contracts, and the other party does not have to check that it did. See Does a parish or community council have to have standing orders?
If a fault comes to light
Where these rules do not settle whether a decision stands, this guide's suggestion is to take the decision again at a later meeting that is properly called and has a quorum, without any barred councillor taking part. These rules do not say what that does for anything already done in reliance on the first decision.
What this page does not cover
Sources
All read as revised.
- Local Government Act 1972, Schedule 12: paragraphs 10 (England) and 26 (Wales), the notice and the summons; 12 (England), 28 (Wales) and 45, the quorum; 39, voting; 41, signed minutes; 43, empty seats and defects; 44, committees
- Local Government Act 1972, sections 82 (what a disqualified person does), 92 (court cases), 135 (contracts) and 270 (meanings)
- Localism Act 2011, sections 28 (the code of conduct), 31 (the bar on taking part), 33 (dispensations) and 34 (the offence)
- The Local Authorities (Model Code of Conduct) (Wales) Order 2008, article 3 and the code's paragraph 14; Local Government Act 2000, section 69B (the Ombudsman's investigation)
- Co-option: rule 5 of the 2006 rules (England) and rule 5 of the 2021 rules (Wales), after a casual vacancy; Representation of the People Act 1985, section 21, after an election with too few candidates
- Public Bodies (Admission to Meetings) Act 1960, section 1 (the public notice)
- Local Government and Elections (Wales) Act 2021, section 47 (attending from elsewhere)
The official website shows each provision as up to date with all changes known to be in force, or as having no known outstanding effects. For paragraph 43 it lists, as not yet applied, an exclusion by section 362(3) of the Planning (Wales) Act 2026, not yet in force, for committees exercising a planning authority's functions; its notes also record one in force for certain planning committees in Wales. The other changes it lists as not yet applied to these provisions do not bear on this page.
Last checked against the source on 17 November 2026.